|
|
2008/05/11
Family to sue over trainee's death
By : Neville Spykerman

Too Jong Sing (right) and his wife Chin Kwei Choo (left) with Pandamaran state assemblyman Ronnie Liu at his service centre yesterday. — Picture courtesy of Nanyang Siang Pau |
KLANG: The family of National Service trainee Too Hui Min will be suing the government over her death last Wednesday.
 |
| Too Hui Min died at the Slim River Hospital last week. |
Hui Min's mother, Chin Kwei Choo, 52, said they were seeking legal action because they did not believe the 18-year-old died of toxic megacolon or infection of the colon. "We cannot accept the official explanation. We are suing to get the truth."
Chin said based on what she heard from her daughter's fellow trainees, camp authorities were slow in taking Hui Min to hospital.
"My daughter may still be alive if they had acted promptly."
Chin said the compensation of RM40,000 and funeral expenses of RM3,000, to be given to the family by the National Service Training Council, was no consolation.
"She is gone for good. Money cannot bring her back."
Chin and her husband, Too Jong Sing, 55, yesterday sought the assistance of Pandamaran state assemblyman Ronnie Liu at his service centre.
Liu, who will assist the family in getting a lawyer, said he would be referring the matter to Batu Gajah MP Fong Po Kuan who is putting in a notice for an emergency motion to debate the tragedy in Parliament.
Liu said he would also be visiting the Geo Kosmo National Service camp to seek answers on behalf of the family. Hui Min was taken to the Slim River Hospital where she died at 10.45pm on Wednesday.
She had complained of an upset stomach during firearms training at a shooting range in Jugra, in Banting, Selangor.
Hui Min was to have completed the NS programme on June 7.
Deaths of NS Trainees
According to various sources, including the Wikipedia, there were 22 fatalities involving National Service trainees since its inception in 2004. Among the listed ones are:
2008:
- May 7: Too Hui Min, 18, passed away three days after complaining of constipation.
- April 16: Afiq Zuhairi, 18, died after a brief febrile illness. He was said to have been treated by camp paramedics several times before being transferred to hospital where he died in less than 24 hours.
2007:
- Jan 18: Ili Ameera Azlan, 17, attached to the Ayer Keroh, Melaka camp, after suffering breathing difficulties
- March 1: P. Prema from Kajang, Selangor, attached to the Kisana Beach Resort Camp, Kelantan, found unconscious in a toilet at Jeram Linang at 2.30am. She was taken to the Tengku Anis Hospital where she was pronounced dead.
- Sept 3: Mohd Rafi Ameer, 18, died at 10.30pm after having fever for 1 week. Rafi called his sister to tell her that he had fever and that his leg had been swollen for nearly a week after he fell during training. His death was the 20th since National Service started in 2004.
2005:
- May 14: Nurul Ashikin Karino, 17, died at the Han Sui, Tawau, Sabah camp. Karino Jalani (father of the deceased) claimed that he was not allowed to meet his daughter who fell and was injured during training.
- June 11: S. Theresa Pauline, 17, attached to the Karisma Camp, Kuala Pilah, Negeri Sembilan. She was admitted to the hospital on May 23 after having fits. Her death was attributed to viral meningoencephaliti.
2004:
- April 25: Awang Mohd Fazil Awang Borhan, 17, was attached to the Simalajau Camp, Bintulu, Sarawak. He wwas drowned while swimming with 36 other trainees at Sungai Cina, Matang, Kuching, Sarawak.
- May 9: T. Saravanan, 18, attached to the South Kelantan Development Authority's (Kesedar) Ethnobotany camp. The trainee from 1614A Hospital Quarters, Taiping, Perak drowned while picknicking at Sungai Taman Wangi, Gua Musang, about 3 kilometres from his camp, with 250 trainees and 10 trainers.
| |
Reader's Comments (Latest Comments Displayed First) |
Cheerfuldragon, London: Is there a cover up for all these deaths? Why are the authorities not questioned and held responsible for these unnecessary deaths. These young people are being entrusted to the country for their health and safety so surely the country should be liable for all these deaths as it is compulsory for them to do NS and therefore the country is responsible for their deaths and answers and compensations should be available without questions. No wonder some people are so fed up with the government as the recent General Election results show.
Desmond, Penang: If every year there is someone pass away from the statics because of some incident whether is negligence or not, someone must review the system. Every year there is someone pass away right from 2004 to 2008 then public can foresee there maybe possibility that someone will die in the next year NS training and I can tell you I am very scared to send my children to NS training!
Lim, Shah Alam: Support for call to 'Stop the National Service Now'. From training, medical, accomodation, management to security and safety, all these must be taken care before NS is allowed to resume. Please debate this publicly.
Tan , Sabah: Shouldn't any trainees complain of sickness be immediately reported to in house clinic and if serious refer to hospital? But why was this not practised? I was surprised that all trainees should be referred to camp commander first, from there he will decide to refer or not to refer for medication. Is commander well-versed and have good knowledge of medication than doctors? No doubt, he may want to know if trainee is reported sick or just pretending to escape other activities. But from the past incident, are all camp commaders willing to take further risk?
Hamilton Bacon: For the 22 tragically lost young lives, let's hope they did not die in vain, for nothing.
Sherman, Negeri Sembilan: After so many deaths for the past 4 years, this programme still failed to wake up the Government to implement more effective approach in handling this issue. Therefore, as an ex-NS trainee, i feel it is just waste of time and wastage of the Rakyats Money.
K V Soon, Subang Jaya: Stop the National Service NOW!
With claims that ALL ISSUES HAVE BEEN IRONED OUT, this NONSENSE (NS) has yet taken another live! This time it is Too Hui Min, a 7-As SPM student who had a bright future ahead of her.
How can entrust the lives of our children to people who do not care, who cry crocodile tears and tell us that everything is ok and fine and whose heart is not really with the children.
I do not intend to send my children to this NON-SENSE. If I go to jail for this - let me be the first to do it because we love our children.
I have said more than enough here, it has been poorly planned from DAY ONE!
Where is Lee Lam Thye who wept at one of the death. How can such an important incident, only a NS Training Council member came out with a statement promised that another internal investigation would be conducted.
Meanwhile the NS Training Department director-general was quoted as saying that the training programme will not be scrapped "just because of one or two deaths". We find this an absolutely insensitive remark when another life was lost.
This is more the reason to STOP THE NS NOW!
Sherley,Johor: Why are these happening so frequently? Can someone give us explanation? Those victims'family are the one who are going to suffer because of the death of their loved one. Can someone unveil the truth to them and the public?
Luqman: "We cannot accept the official explanation. We are suing to get the truth. She is gone for good. Money cannot bring her back."
If the family thinks money won't ease the pain, they shouldn't go for a lawsuit. Instead, they should file a criminal charge. That would reveal more truth than just a lawsuit.
Brian, Batu Pahat: The NS Programme should be scrapped. I do not see the positive side of this programme other than misery to families of the 22 dead trainees. The NS Programme should be reviewed.
|
|
RELATED STORIES
|
|
OTHER STORIES |
-
Tasty Kelantanese delights
-
'Nicol has distinguished herself'
-
Abrupt end to wild party
-
Pits stop diesel polluting river
-
Music as a message of peace
-
Home news in brief: Abduction bid foiled
-
Voter nod for elected local councillors
-
RHB-NST Spell-It-Right Challenge: Isaac returns to nail the top spot
-
The Enid Blyton path to success
-
45,000 govt contract staff in a spot over work status
-
Spotlight: Game for some swinging, dear?
-
Sweet singing by Kelabit band
-
New buses, low fares and better service
-
Statements ‘not a personal attack’
-
Abdullah ready for talks with discuss with Pas
-
Plantation staff contractors must register
-
Home news in brief: Panthers on the prowl
-
'Proton needs foreign partner'
-
From violence to beauty
-
Blind, yet he saved many lives
-
Bid to gazette Kinta Nature Park as a state park
-
Stick to plan, preserve Penang’s heritage
-
4 'royal' imposters arrested
-
Yet another bomb detonated safely at campus site
-
How to stir children's interest
-
'Students are not reading the right way'
-
Reading for all the write reasons
-
Try not to be duped, women told
-
Outbreak blamed on outside food
-
RHB-NST Spell-It-Right Challenge: It's a teary win after tense tie-breaker
-
RHB-NST Spell-It-Right Challenge: Confident Angeline comes out tops
-
Now businesses can renew licences any time
-
Ringgit & sense: Kitchen diaries of 12 Malaysian families
-
Wholesome meals at minimal cost
-
Who will be Tee Keat's deputy?
-
PKR duo settle matter
-
Koh: Look at students' background when giving grants
-
Hitmen fire 30 shots
-
Paying for the sins of their fathers
-
Asean foreign ministers to ratify charter at meeting
-
RM2b Penang Sentral to be ready by 2015
-
Penang gets RM140m for buses, hill railway
-
It's now Datuk Muszaphar
-
Ruler: Be patient dealing with rising food prices
-
Terengganu sultan not conferring awards
-
Anwar's proposals banditry, says Shahrir
-
'Umno members free to nominate candidates'
-
Call to help win back 'no-visa' requirement
-
Convention calls for greater Bumiputera advancement
-
Go easy, Najib tells banks
-
'Take care of nature's gifts'
-
Two burnt to death in crash
-
No meddling in Inul affair
-
NewsFocus: 'The best way to manage foreign labour'
-
NewsFocus: Good example of foreign labour management
-
NewsFocus: Terribly underpaid, they want to go home
-
NewsFocus: Procedures are unclear
|
MOST READ TODAY! |
|
|
|