|
![]() Thursday, January 08, 2009, 05.02 AM |
|
NST Online » Columns
2008/12/03ZAINUL ARIFIN: Superior national schools will help
By : ZAINUL ARIFIN
|
|
Talk back to us. Click on the button below.
|
|
Korom, Kota Kinabalu: Omar of Shah Alam hit some very good points. But he failed to elaborate what perhaps is the most important one, which is turning Bahasa Malaysia into a language of research, technology . That's where the problem lies, right at the top tier of the education system in our universities. How many of us are really convinced that our universities employ, or for that matter, make an effort to employ the best academicians to come out of the country? How many of our university VC can seriously claim to be the best person for the job instead of being the best-connected with certain non-academic circles? Until people can answer these questions wthout any embarassment, there's no point of talking about making Bahasa Malaysia into a language to gain knowledge. I must add, to make the langauge acceptable to all, no one race or group of people should claim sole ownership of the language itself. No one race or group should have the right to determine the limits of how, where or when the language can be used by "others". This should not be seen as a "sacrifice" by the Malays but instead they should be proud of the its outcome. All this would be the first step to make Bahasa Malaysia the truly national language. Pragmatists may agree with me in varying degrees but my guess is that many ultras would not be too happy with my suggestion. I don't know which category Datuk Mukhriz falls into. bini,Malaysian in Australia: If we are serious about national unity, we should conduct an in depth study on the causes of racial polarization in Malaysia. Blaming the vernacular schools will only cause more tension among the different races. It is important to know that both national schools and vernacular schools follow the same national curriculum. Teachers in both type of schools are trained under a unified teacher training program. Moreover, the vernacular schools accept children from different races. Currently there are a substantial number of bumiputra students that are attending the vernacular schools. Therefore, there is no solid reason to accuse the vernacular schools as the cause of racial disunity in Malaysia. If we value racial integration, we must also question the needs for the existence of fully residential schools, Mara junior science colleges and UiTM. How about the racial based University Matriculation System and the high school STPM system? Lastly, we must also look at the racial imbalance in the public service. It is important to know that we only spend about 10 to 15 years in the schools, but we are going to spend the rest of our life as working individuals. Fadhil: Dear Zainul, I am in total agreement with what you wrote in your opinion piece today and you have raised many pertinent questions which I feel should be high on every politician's agenda. There is indeed a 'high level of hypocrisy' where our education system is concerned and our poor children, the future leaders of tomorrow will suffer for it. I also applaud Datuk Mukhrizs' bold statement, if not only to shake everybody out of their complacency altho closing down vernacular schools might be too harsh. I have 4 schoolgoing children, 3 in national schools, the other in university and am shocked everytime I visit their school to see how very few non-malays there unlike our times, in the national english schools. You can actually count them with the fingers of one hand. How can you expect these children to know about the other races, their cultures, their traditions, their religion, their festivals and hope to build a bangsa Malaysia. It is a very sad day indeed when our children do not have homes to visit during Chinese New Year or Deepavali because they do not have many friends of that race or do not know them close enough to be invited into their homes. The same goes for children in vernacular schools. what values are we teaching our children. i truly believe most of our social ills today can be solved by our politicians spending more time on educating our children better ... to prepare them better for the challenges they will face tomorrow. Not just spending eons deciding whether English or Bm is better for science and maths. the fact of the matter is, no matter what, our children's overall standard of English MUST be improved otherwise they will lose out in their education or job opportunities. The language of Oil for eg is English. how can you expect a Malaysian to do global deals when he /she can't even string an English sentence together. I say bravo to Datuk Mukhriz for trying to stop this rot. too much talk and no action. no political will. Tan Sri Ramon Navaratnam: Saudara Zainul, I enjoyed your good Article on National Schools Its become topical again - with Mukhris's comments . Would you pursue this important issue and try to get some consensus please ? Mohamadon Abdullah/Shah Alam: I agree with Moaz of Subang and his views, and his well-thought-out and articulate proposals. However, on a different note, I must agree with Balachandran of Shah Alam that if national unity and unifying Malaysian is the real concerns, then we must disband all discriminatory policies and establishments as outlined by him. Bangsa Malaysia cannot and will not be achieved when some segments are treated differently and accorded special treatments. Moaz, Subang Jaya: My view is pretty simple: Organization & Basics *1 school system *B. Malaysia is the medium of instruction *students must also learn English from the earliest years until the end of SPM *Tamil, Mandarin Chinese, Iban, Hokkien Chinese, Cantonese Chinese, Punjabi and other languages should be available as elective courses *All teachers in national schools must be fluent & literate in Bahasa Malaysia and 1 other language at the very minimum *All teachers must undergo cultural sensitivity training and demonstrate their knowledge and understanding inside and outside the schools Representation at the Local Level *School boards (set at the district level) *School and Community Organization/School Council - including residents, local council members, elected trustees, and school heads Other programs/programme options *School-within-a-school - this concept would be allowed only when it can be proven that this school will not create divisions in the student body *Sponsorships - schools may receive sponsorship from outside bodies, corporations, etc. provided that it is approved in the local council and school board *Immersion program - students can choose to take all of their studies in 1 language provided that the requirements for B.Malaysia are met in every year of study. In addition to Bahasa Malaysia, students may choose to study a language that is not the immersion language as an elective course - choices could include: English, Mandarin Chinese, Cantonese Chinese, Hokkien Chinese, Tamil, Iban, Punjabi, etc. Curriculum well, let's leave that for another day.... KCL: Your article in the NST 03 dec 2008 has suggested the improvement of national schools in order to attract the attendance of non-Malay students. One important element, beside other considerations for the Education Ministry, is that the authority should take the teaching of English, Chinese and Tamil very seriously, as you have rightly advovated. The government can in this respect emulate the education system in Singapore where they have successfully persuaded the Chinese to send their children to English medium national schools. However I am pessimistic that singapore's success can be replicated in Malaysia because of likely opposition from UMNO politicians and powerful Malay language lobbies. Rajan,Ipoh: I dont agree vernacular school is the cause of race polarisation. infact no vernacular school is teaching RACE BASHING subject. The kids studying in the vrnacular school are too young to understand racial politics. If national school can bring unity,please ask the parents who sends the children to NS ,the amount of racial slur,abuses,discrimation practise by certain teachers from certain race against other races. It is the policy practises by certain paries which cause racial disunity and not the school system. If government wants the NS to be choice of the people then it must ensure that it is NOT monopolized and dominated by one race. The school administration should be racially balanced and and alot of non malays should be given chance to become headmasters and the school HM should be sensitive to the feeling of other races. If MUKHRIZ is very serious in his agenda why he never ask institution like UITM, MARA to be abolished. When the government of the day practises fairness, treat every race fairly and gives equal distribution of the wealth to all races, u will not see this racial disunity. Yew Meng: Dear zainul, yes, i too believe that a single school system will a be a major factor in promoting national integration. in a chinese school, where perhaps 95% are chinese, its natural that the thinking is bias towards entirely chinese culture, and likewise the rest. in the national school, assuming its 58% malay, 28% chinese, 8% indians and 6% the rest, the mood HAS to be mixed, with stronger malay slant - and thats malaysian! however, i also believe this single school system can never ever have any headstart as long as they are generally not attractive. i have heard many complaints over long periods by malay parents that if they wanted to send their children to SAR schools, they would have done so. so there you go! {i was schooled in st xavier's in penang from 1961. i cannot remember any instance when i felt any segregation between catholics and non. there was an option to attend cathecacism {hope spelling is correct} classes. to address this by zeroing on the vernacular schools simply cant't work. ong tee keat can lock chua soi lek in the store room, and can get away with it. may even get some applause. support the closure of chinese schools? its suicide, period. even the umno president-in-waiting can't do it. the key, which clearly you enunciated is SUPERIOR NAT SCHOOLS WILL DO NICELY..... just a little indulgence. the british left us a terrific administration. history the world over has recorded that former spanish colonies are did badly, mostly. british admin is far superior, unless the rules are changed by the locals. how can we make our beloved nation better? i want to think simple but with loads of common sense. i only have a 3-step solution: promote and ingrain upon all authority figures the concept of PLURALISM - that it exists and can never ever disappear. EDUCATION - teacher's salary scheme be upgraded another 3 levels. schools and the education budget increased another 30%. that there be 2 education related ministries. the best in the land will be attracted to this noblest of vocations. POLICE - upgrade their scheme another 3 levels. its automatic that the corruption will have much less to do. the public will be safe, the commercial world will volunteer to self regulate, etc etc etc what's the real difference between singapore and malaysia. the PAP wants and gets unfettered political power, then they proceed to do what's right, without consideration for any pandering. the BN, actually UMNO has the same attitude in the power aspect, but then proceeds to pander. what a waste! now the power's diminishing, and not strong enough to be rough and tough. my dear, zainul, i always read your column, cause i know you always have something to say. not just to say something. cheers. Victor: Zainul, I am the product of the vanacular schools and so is my childeren. Let me share my views with you: Yes, superior national schools will encourage parents like myself to sent my children to national schools. At this moment, we are in opinion that national schools are inferior to vanacular schools: they focus on Malay culture and Malay religion and the teachers are less passionate about their job. There is kind of "ketuanan melayu" in such schools. I do not want our children to feel inferior at this stage. Sending all children to national school is not a factor to unit our next generation. My boys are in national type secondary schools now. They learnt most subject in Malay and has a big number of Malay class mates and teachers. They still don't mixed. They may be young. They are not naive. They knew they are not the same as the Malay class mates. Religion, language and race is not what sepeerated them. It's the reality of life in Malaysia: They knew they must do better in the examinations, otherwise life will be doomed. They knew the universities placement, schoolar ships and career will not be distributed the same for Malay and non-Malay. Without same feeling and goal in life, how can they be good buddies? They are not seperated because they never study in the same primary school. They are seperated because they will be treated differently because of their skin and religion. I wish to see Malaysia to be united and away from all the racist issues. I want my grand children can be educated in national schools. My defination of superior school is where there is no ketuanan melayu, which is secular, with passionate school teacher, with useful educational materials and with freedom to learn any other langauge, be it mother tongue or not. I hope you can a different perspective from one from vanucular schools and convey this msg to the politicians. Omar,Shah Alam: Two Tamil speaking girls were passing in front of my house one day chattering happily. But their chatter were not in Tamil, they were in Bahasa Malaysia. However, this happened long time ago,which was in the eighties when the national school became the choice for all. But alas, today with politicians clamouring for power and popularity the scene above had become just a memory. They have not succeeded in promoting unity but instead they widened disunity. They made the Chinese and Indians send their children to their respecting vernacular schools. They demand this and that. Any suggestion made to remedy this were look upon as seditious as what happened to suggestions made by Dato'Mukhriz Mahathir. As long as these politicians continue with their racial politic the future is bleak. I agree with Dato'Mukhriz and I also agree with En.Zainul Ariffin that the national school must be strong and superior.To do that in the first place we have to make Bahasa Malaysia strong and be accepted by all Malaysian. Let Bahasa Malaysia be the medium of instruction in Mathematics and Science again. Turn it into a language of research, technology and a language to gain knowledge.Dewan Bahasa and Pustaka must play its part. More books must be churned out,technology terms must be made available.Get more people to translate books into Bahasa Malaysia. Get writers to write more books.Give insentive to these people. As for English, its teaching must be revamped,more oral work must be done in class. Dialogue and acting with different situation each week must be done every week.Introduce English literature in the primary school where the children can be tough to think and express in English and put more non Malays school teachers in the national school.At the same time,introduce Tamil and Mandarin subjects. The politicians must play their part,forget about ethnics,forget about popularity,just think of national unity. The goverment must be serious in tackling this problem,they must take action straight away,no more talking, no more this 'to please others' attitude.Pump more fun into the national primary schools. Upgrade the building and facilities,make the teachers and children proud of their school and make sure the fun are being made to good use. The future of our children and country are in your hand. Simon Khor: All my 3 children are in Chinese Primary schools. I do agrre with you the National shold be better than all other schools to make people wanting to send their school there. 1. The cleanliness of the school canteen at national school need alot of improvement if compare to a chinese school ( SRJK Lee Rubber, Gombak ). 2. The security of national school are so lacking,, any body can walk in and out. 3. Teacher in NS are always on leave. 4. In 1950s all NS are one level ahead of all other school but its has since drop after 1970s. 5. Many more.... Simon KNewchief, kota kinabalu: Going to school is to GAIN KNOWLEDGE !!! Balachandran, Shah Alam: Dear Mr Zainul, I respect your views. But what about UITM, UIAM, MARA, MRSM, PASUM, special matriculation colleges which are confined to a certain race? What about discount to buy houses, special priveleges for scholarships, loans, tenders, government jobs? Does all of the above contribute to national unity and a unified Malaysia. It is always easy to pick on others while you sit tight in your palace. Thank you and salam hormat. Bala |
|
|
| TEXT ADS |
Avoid Erectile Dysfunction / Diabetes / Stroke
|
ONLINE atHOME, INCOME IN USDXXXX
|
Lose WEIGHT Now ! Reshape - 2009
|
| Advertise With Us Here! |
| WEEKEND READ | ||||
|
||||
|
|
|
|
| Write to the Editor for editorial enquiry or Sales Department for sales and advertising enquiry. Copyright © 2008 NST Online. All rights reserved. |