Columnists

Three reasons why Vladimir Putin wants Ukraine

Vladimir Putin's obsession with Ukraine stems from a few reasons, with the first being his refusal to reconcile with Russia's past.

Putin grew up during the golden years of the Soviet Union, and before it collapsed, he served as a KGB agent in East Germany.

The Soviet fall in 1991 took a personal toll on Putin, including forcing him to drive taxis to make ends meet.

In April 2005, Putin described the Soviet fall as the "greatest geopolitical catastrophe" of this century, and last December, he called the independence of former Soviet colonies a "major humanitarian tragedy".

So, for Putin, losing Ukraine – the largest former Soviet state besides Russia – to Western embrace is non-negotiable.

After the Euromaidan Revolution in 2014 toppled the Moscow-backed Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanukovych, Putin retaliated by annexing Crimea.

He also backed rebel groups in Donetsk and Luhansk provinces to cut ties with Ukraine and recently the breakaway regions as independent nations.

Now, he wants to tighten his grip on Ukraine before it slips further away from Moscow's embrace.

The second reason is Putin's contention with the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (Nato).

Nato, initially formed in 1949 to curb Soviet expansionism, began welcoming former Soviet states after the Cold War ended.

Under Article 5 of the Washington Treaty, Nato guarantees collective security for all its members. This means that if one Nato member is attacked, the other members are legally obligated to roll out military support to the affected member.

To Putin, the enlargement of Nato meant that the West is encircling Russia and closing in on her borders.

Russia is already bordered by four Nato members –Norway, Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia – and Ukraine was close to becoming the fifth.

In December 2021, Putin demanded Nato withdraw troops back to its 1997 position and deny membership for former Soviet states, including Georgia and Ukraine.

Before Putin, his predecessor, Boris Yeltsin, insisted his then US counterpart Bill Clinton do the same in 1997. But, Clinton refused.

This time, Putin is adamant about Moscow's demands to be heard.

The third reason is, of course, the economy.

Russia supplies almost 40 per cent of Europe's natural gas, with Germany being the biggest importer. In fact, oil and gas make up two-thirds of Russia's export revenues.

Ukraine plays a pivotal role in Russia's natural gas trade, as the two major pipelines transporting Russia's gas to Western Europe – Bratstvo and Soyuz – passes through Ukraine. Bratstvo is also Russia's largest pipeline to Europe.

This allows Ukraine to earn about US$2 billion in transit fees from Russia every year.

However, over the years, Russia has tried to reduce, and eventually eliminate reliance on Ukraine for its natural gas trade. The Nord Stream pipeline, which directly links Russia to Germany, is one such effort.

After the Nord Stream commenced operations in 2011, Russia's natural gas exports to Europe through Ukraine dwindled by 30 to 40 per cent.

The Nord Stream 2 pipeline project, which Germany has halted after the Ukraine invasion, was also meant to double Russia's natural gas exports to Germany.

In 2019, Putin agreed to pay Ukraine transit fees worth over US$7 billion to continue shipping gas to Europe through Ukraine until 2024.

But, he did that reluctantly after the US passed sanctions against Nord Stream 2.

Controlling Ukraine, thus, allows Putin to bolster Russia's gas trade and even leverage natural gas supply as a bargaining chip against Europe.

This also means that economic sanctions against Russia will inevitably hurt Europe.

So, how long is Europe willing to pay the price before Putin agrees to listen?


The writer is a New Straits Times journalist

The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect those of the New Straits Times

Most Popular
Related Article
Says Stories